For my Sunday Starbucks friends who were debating, who in the church (or outside the church) were ‘heretics'. The source here is a quote from my Anglican Prayer Book Dictionary.
HERESY, HERETIC.
These words are not of common occurrence in the Prayer Book, but their use may be illustrated from the suffrage in the Litany which asks for deliverance "from all false doctrine, heresy; and schism," and from the 3rd Collect for Good Friday, which prays for mercy on "all Jews, Turks, Infidels and Heretics." In other passages there is a reference to the subject without any use of the word itself, e.g., in the question put to bishops and priests as to their readiness "to banish and drive away all erroneous and strange doctrines contrary to God's Word."
["Heresy, in law, is only that which has, before 1559, been adjudged so to be by the authority of the canonical scriptures, or by any of the first four General Councils, or by any other General Council wherein the same was declared" heresy by the express words of the canonical scriptures, or which, since 1559. may have been, or may be, determined to be heresy by Parliament with the assent of the clergy in Conv." Halsbury's Laws of Eng., 1910, 11 653, thus summarises the still valid definition in I Eliz. c. I. s. 20, and adds in n., "where a clerk is accused of heresy, the arts. of charge must distinctly state the obnoxious opinions and the exact terms in which he has uttered or published them."—G. H.]
The words "heresy" and "heretic" came into the English language from the Latin haeresis, haereticus. The former word denotes (1) choice, selection, (2) the tenets of a school or sect, or the sect itself; hence it was applied to the self-willed adoption by individual Christians of doctrines or principles divergent from those of the Church: the "heretic" is the man who adopts such opinions. Both words are found, the latter only once, in the NT (I Cor. 11:19, Gal. 5:20; Titus 3:10), but in the NT the meaning is rather factiousness than doctrinal error.
Yet the dangers to which the Church was to be exposed from Heretic Were already felt in the Apostolic age and are clearly pointed out in some of the later books of the NT. e.g., Col., Pastoral epistles, the epistles of Saint John, 2, Peter, Jude, and Rev. (see esp. Col 2:8; I Tim. 4: 1-8, 6:3, 20; 2 Tim. 2:17; I John 2:22; 2 John, v.7; Rev. 2:6, 14). Some of these Heresy were with regard to the Incarnation, amounting to a denial that JESUS CHRIST had come in the flesh (2 John, v.7); others involved a denial of future Resurrection (2 Tim. 2:18), or were connected with a perverted asceticism (1 Tim. 4:1-5). Against these and similar errors the Apostolic writings contain frequent and emphatic warnings, and in one passage (Titus 3:10) Saint Paul enjoins absolute avoidance of the "heretic" who remains deaf to expostulation.
The NT, therefore, contains plain traces of the first beginnings of the heresies—derived from various sources, such as Judaism, Oriental religions, Greek philosophy—which vexed the Church (esp. in the East) in the first centuries of her life in such forms as Docetism, Gnosticism and Manicheism. It is outside the limits of this article to describe the growth of these heresies, or of the later heresies of the 4th and 5th cents. with regard to the Person of Christ or the God-head of the Holy Spirit.
The Church was, from the first, alive to the danger, and a long succession of writers (such as Justin Martyr, Irenaeus, Clement of Alexandria, Tertullian, Epiphanius and Augustine) devoted themselves to controverting heresy. When Provincial or General Councils became possible, conciliar action was resorted to, as in the notable instance of Arianism. The recognition of Christianity by the State soon led to the adoption of coercive methods of dealing with heretics and schismatics, and Saint Augustine in his later writings justified and advocated this course, which was, unhappily, adopted by the Church, and carried into effect for many centuries. (See also CHURCH, SCHISM. For full accounts of earlier heresies, see arts. in DCB (Biography); and for heresies in all periods. J. H. Blunt, Dictionary of Sects, Heresies. etc., 1874.) -K2
WALTER HOBHOUSE.
[NOTE:] Another subject they requested was on marriage. I'm sure they wont be pleased to see what the Church has to say on this subject. /Francis